Days before Christmas, Jonas and Beth Byler and their six-month-old baby, Zac, are driving in their buggy when it is forced off the road. They are rushed to the hospital where it is confirmed that Zac escaped injury, and Beth has a broken leg. Jonas has not regained consciousness. Beth must rely on hospital staff to help care for baby Zac, who remains by her bed. When Beth wakes the next morning, she finds her baby is missing. When the police search is unsuccessful, Beth's faith is tested. With anger welling within, she fights the instinct to lay blame on God, the hospital staff, and herself. Will Beth ever see her baby again? What will she tell her husband when he recovers? When Jonas regains consciousness on Christmas morning, will he open his eyes to see his wife and baby?