In the autumn of 1892 two young people were kidnapped from a dinner party at the home of Marcus and Faerie Wright. Without pause, only one suspect was named: Reginald O'Keefe. O'Keefe and his Voices were on a quest for revenge. Weeks after the incident Sheriff Johnson received word of a possible sighting on Red Mountain. While a search party combed the forest, the citizens of Ouray waited anxiously for word of the teen's rescue and capture of O'Keefe. Some were in favor of swift justice. Others simply wanted his reign of terror to end. Another man, Doc Fisher, would test the judicial system by researching mental illness and presenting it to the prosecution in an effort to ensure justice was fair. Will O'Keefe torment the teens or set them free? Will he turn himself in or go further into hiding? Will he get the help he so desperately needs or sink deeper into his psychosis?