Curtis Curly-tail, the perfectly-sized lizard from Warderick Wells, hears something noisy in the night. It's Horace Hutia and his family, crunching on leaves. Curtis Curly-tail meets Horace, an endangered Bahamian hutia, a new resident of Warderick Wells. The colony of hutias are damaging the cay's ecosystem. Scientists arrive to help, but what will happen to Horace? This book has several endings with different ways to solve the problem. The reader decides which ending would help the hutias most.