What happens to the lively youngest Shantz girl, Moira, when she shocks her family by taking a job as a teacher far from home? Moira doesn't want to end up like her two older sisters who are married with children, so jumps at the teaching opportunity that the bishop suggests. Moira meets other men in her new Amish community, but her mind opens to more of what the world has to offer when she meets an English doctor. Will Moira find love and happiness away from Tom, the only Amish man she has ever loved?