Rudolph Vincenzo can't seem to avoid trouble. In Asbury, the eleven-year-old finds himself on the wrong side of a hockey-stick-swinging rival. Black and blue, Rudolph looks to FingerTip Island for help -- only to find his supernatural escape changing for the worse. Strange faces have Rudolph suspicious and fighting time, as both the island and his friends take to a bad influence. Cryptic warnings and a missing baby sister make FingerTip Island more unpredictable than ever. Rudolph, June, Gus, and St Peter -- joined by a mysterious island native -- try to find the lost toddler Vincenzo and restore order to the island. But newcomers seem intent on stopping them, and Rudolph discovers they are not without their own powers. Relying on more than his imagination, Rudolph is forced to find a way to save his friends and FingerTip Island from a shadowy, dark force.