Sheldon Madison got a job offer she could not refuse which returned her home to the town she grew up in, Cedar Falls, Montana. She had no idea she would not only end up working with Nathan Holt, the boy she had a crush on in school but ended up dating her best friend, but vying for the same job promotion as editor of their small town newspaper, The Prickly Press. One day, Sheldon unexpectedly found a stack of lost love letters on a bus which would lead her on an investigation to find the owner. Solving this mystery would lead her down a path that would uncover answers to her own questions she had been longing to reveal. The love letters would end up changing the course of her own life in more ways than one. Will Sheldon find the rightful owner of the love letters and will she find love for herself in the process?