In 1965, Tim O'Malley returns to his home town of Skitter Lake, Ohio, to clear his name and get the girl: Dorothy Whitaker, the love of his life since eighth grade. Blamed for a destructive fire he didn't set, only Tim and Dorothy know the truth; that Jesse Prescott, Tim's best friend and Dorothy's boyfriend, did the deed that changed an entire town. But Jesse died in that tragedy and seven years later, Skitter Lake still honors him as a hero, rather than Tim, the boy from the seedy side of town whose father was a drunk . . . and whose quick actions saved six people from perishing in that horrendous fire. In trying to set the record straight and finally claim Dorothy as his own, Tim-and Dorothy, too-will discover that in some small towns the legend often outweighs the truth . . . and their family and friends will forever see Dorothy as "Jesse's girl."