Molly Campbell has been in love with Caleb Johnson most of her life. After becoming his friend in high school and working up the courage for two years, she is finally ready to make her move. Caleb is moving home from college for the summer and she intends to move out of the friend zone and into the girlfriend zone. But what happens when, on the night of Caleb's supposed homecoming, Molly finds herself at his older brother Noah's welcome home party. Molly and Noah wake up the next morning in bed together and decide to forget the night's "mistake." While Molly tries desperately to get Caleb to notice her and stay away from his brother, she realizes she may be chasing the wrong brother. Can she learn to let go of her feelings for the boy she thought she loved and acknowledge her feelings for the man who deserves them? Noah Johnson was used to taking care of his siblings. His parents were drug addicts that neglected their children, making Noah feel like a parent from a young age. After his parents overdose and the siblings are adopted by a loving family, Noah no longer has to take care of his brother and sister even though it is in his nature. When he realizes that he wants the girl that has been in love with his brother for years he must finally learn to let go of his protectiveness of his brother and start to think about what he wants and go for it.