Olivia Kennedy Kimsey is in her late fifties, recently divorced, nearly broke and attempting to deal with single life and a nonconformist daughter. Self-hypnosis had brought some calm to her life and a restful night's sleep when the visions began-Olivia prefers to call them dreams-from a young murdered woman named Vickie Taylor. The dreams lead Olivia to uncover the unsolved murders of four women who had belonged to the cougar website: Fish In The Sea. Each woman's profile stated that they were looking for an honest man, and that simple statement set them up for murder. Enlisting the help of her daughter Samantha and Samantha's friend Wally, Olivia is drawn into a dangerous financial scam of lonely, older women. It becomes personal when Olivia's childhood friend Gretchen shares her own surprise: she is a member of Fish In The Sea, and she's found exactly what she's been looking for: an honest man.