Dwaine Tinsley, as the cartoon editor for Larry Flint's notorious Hustler magazine, had assembled a staff of cartoonists whose unprecedently offensive socio-sexual cartoons spearheaded that publication's fight against the forces of censorship and repression. Tinsley's primary contribution was Chester the Molester, a hulking middle-aged man who craved pre-pubescent girls. Tinsley's daughter accused of him of sexually violating her over the course of five years. This is the story of Tinsley's trial and the story of his family life.