Rebekah Bontrager has loved and planned to marry Seth Graber since they were children. She shocks everyone in her community including Seth, when she up and marries an older man in another district. Her parent's furniture store is in trouble and Henry offers to save it, if she will marry him, with one condition. Everyone has to think they married for love and she can't tell anyone the real reason, or Henry will stop his financial support. Once they are married Rebekah quickly realizes she's made a big mistake. Henry only wants a housekeeper and cook. There will be no children and he is cranky and impossible to please. Amish marry for life, so is Rebekah stuck in a loveless marriage, or is it in God's plan for Henry to have a change of heart?