Seventeen-year-old Meg Flannigan isn't very self-confident, but what girl would be after her sophomore-year boyfriend dumped her by making out with another girl in front of her locker? Now a senior, Meg catches the eye of not one but two guys at school. They vie over her attention, and both are gorgeous. Sounds good, right? Not if one of the guys is her boyfriend and the other one wants to be. Meg doesn't want to lose Ash. They've been together for almost five months, and she's falling in love with him. But Noah. Ah, Noah. He's the irresistible guy Meg has been crushing on for two years, and Meg isn't ready to send him away either. But if she strings both along, she might be the one left in the cold.