The topic of Punjab is sensitive in India and Pakistan because of 1947 massacres which killed around 500,000 or more people. By and large speakers who discussed the book were non committal and tactful . Pakistani security agencies who failed in actual intelligence operational work in all wars scanned the seminar venue. Indian speakers who were very cordial in discussion with all of us took our e mail contacts but never contacted us Now about Punjab history and its partition in 1947 ? How to sum it up Punjabi Hindus who lost the most economically and socially bear responsibility the most for it . Simply because they regarded Punjabi Muslims, Punjabs 54 % majority as socially inferior and in 1920s declared that if ever Muslims in Punjab were allowed actual 54 % electoral share in elections Punjab should be divided And they lost the most Somehow except Prof Rajmohan everyone missed the point that it was British manipulation that won And it is ironic that today India and Pakistan despite all claims of peace are actually heading towards a major war Somehow no one in the whole gathering was admitting that British policy had the last laugh in 1947 by keeping India and Pakistan unstable by mutual fear for all times to come