Always the reasonable one, college professor Elaina Woods prides herself on her level-headedness and maturity. But when she finds herself falling for an attractive and charming man on campus, she's determined not to let herself get swept up in unrealistic dreams of a fairy-tale romance--despite the sparks that fly every time she sees him.

Always the romantic, Anna Woods yearns for the day she is swept off her feet by a wealthy, handsome man and they live happily ever after. When a chance meeting with a stranger leads to exactly the type of exciting and romantic relationship she's always dreamed of, Anna is sure she has met her true prince charming.

As history catches up to the present and hearts are broken, can the sisters overlook their differences and trust that God knows the ultimate plan?