Reality bites. That's what Sydney Eatonton thinks after being reunited with the man who betrayed her. Problem is, Ethan - Lieutenant Ethan Calhoun of Atlanta's Finest - hasn't forgotten her for thirteen years. He plans to show her he's changed for the better except his bumbling antics alienate her instead. He doesn't realize his efforts are in vain since she loves another man. His brother Logan. Logan Calhoun never forgot Sydney either. After his brother Ethan cheated on her, Sydney left town, leaving Logan with plenty of regret considering he too made a fool of himself with her. Now that she's back in Atlanta, Logan intends to show Sydney how much he loves her and finds a unique way to express his feelings for her. Unfortunately for Logan, his plans for "happily ever after" run into plenty of obstacles, the biggest being Ethan.