Piper is a barista at a popular coffee shop, where a new weekly patron has captivated her. Even more so than the anonymous blogger, the "Controversial Lesbian", who she's been following and has been in love with for the past three years. With the lure of a shy closed lip smile, Piper is drawn to the beautiful woman, determined to get to know her. When the anonymous blogger decides to strip her digital mask, revealing her true identity, the surprise unveiling is shocking and life changing. Piper learns that even a lesbian can learn a few things about gender identity and sexuality.