From the time she was a child, Carly Shepherd has gazed at the silent stars in the night sky of her home in Bethlehem, North Carolina. With her childhood overshadowed by her father's abandonment and mother's alcoholism, she wonders how anyone can believe in an equally silent God. After all, she's not felt his presence any more than her earthly father. Though she remembers Christmas pageants and attending church as a child, she no longer has any use for what she considers fairy tales. Drew Middleton is seeking shelter from a rain storm when he walks into Carly's vendor tent at a fall festival, but he's quickly taken with the talented artist and her creations. Feeling an instant connection, Carly is confused by her feelings, especially when she discovers his spiritual commitment. Carly's past and their chance of future together collide when she's snared into refurbishing sets for a Christmas pageant with Drew's help. Will their shared experience bring about a spiritual awakening in Carly this Christmas? Or will time run out as the stars continue to shine silently over Bethlehem?