Tragedy opens like a book when Dustin's mama is murdered, and it seems that each new page reveals more about his daddy's true character. Over and over Dustin watches as Daddy turns the other cheek. When Daddy refuses to lie to Broken Elk, and leaves their family in danger, Dustin's faith in God is shaded with doubt. Is Daddy hiding behind honesty so he won't have to fight? Dustin determines to avenge Mama's death even if Daddy is a coward. Will Aunt Lilly's prayer for a miracle be answered? And who really stole the cattle money from the people in Cimarron Crossing?