Meet Jess and Stephanie. Two very different women, both fiercely independent, but one whose history with men is cluttered with catastrophe, while the other seems to cruise through life without a care in the world, moving from one relationship to the next. When Irish band Punch Drunk comes to town, Stephanie finds herself in the middle of a fiery fling with the overly charming bass player, James. Soon after, Jess is pursued by the roughish lead singer. Robbie is hard to resist and eager to win her over, trying everything he can to get in her good graces. Jess battles with heart and mind. While Robbie reminds her of a past that still haunts her, he could be just what she needs to move on. Can she adopt her best friend's carefree attitude to love for once? However, when tragedy strikes, Jess is the last person who wants to admit she was right all along.