The nature of Vladimir Putin's Russia and how to deal with it is one of the very rare topics in International Relations where there is virtually no disagreement within the American establishment. In 'Foreign Affairs' and other professional journals, we see that opinion is divided over possible responses to Iran and its nuclear policy. Opinion is divided on managing relations with rising China. Only the Russian case appears to be frozen in time, without any public controversy. That is an unnatural state of affairs. For America's national interests to be properly served, for opportunities to lower the transaction costs of managing global affairs to be properly exploited, there must be rigorous debate over relations with Russia, alongside other major foreign policy challenges. The author of these essays has chosen to 'step out of line' and step up to bat. The Bush administration closed and the Obama administration opened amidst global tensions of a New Cold War with the Kremlin. Notwithstanding 'reset, ' the four years since have failed to bring about a significant rapprochement. 'Stepping Out of Line' is a collection of journalistic reports chronicling the ups and downs in relations; the author's polemical ripostes to leading figures in the American foreign policy establishment over responsibility for the missed opportunity to improve relations; and his scholarly essays on American Russianists from the past who demonstrated that profound knowledge of the object of their studies and sympathy for the country were not always at odds