Jack Cain moved his family to Sugar Creek, Oklahoma due to his job promotion as Judge of several counties in the territory. His wife Clare, hoped they were making the right move. Jack and Clare had four children. Cate and Cara were teenagers and weren't happy about the move. Younger son, Jax, and his sister Carly, were excited to be moving out west. The family settled in and learned to adapt. Judge Jack Cain and Marshal Will Cain discovered they were cousins. Jack told Will the story of their distorted past and their connection to each other. Trouble brewed in Sugar Creek. The Cooper gang came to town causing trouble for Marshal Cain and his deputy, Ty Gordon. A kidnapping took place which left the town in turmoil. At age sixteen, Cara met Patrick Stern and knew that one day she would marry him. Would their love survive until she was old enough to marry? Cate met Heath Wallace and Johnny Garner. Heath wanted Cate; Cate wanted Johnny. Johnny was afraid of being hurt again and refused to return her affection. She knew that one day she would tame his heart. Meanwhile, Heath had a plan. He took drastic measures to have Cate and landed himself in a heap of trouble. Would True Love prevail in the end?