It's September 1968, and Howard Knox freshman Annemarie Vanderhorst is happy to be free of her controlling mother's societal expectations. She vows to spend her time at college wisely in pursuit of her own dreams. But before she can figure out what she wants from life, Henry Eden, the dark and handsome stranger in her philosophy class, takes over every waking thought. Nearly half a century later, Claire James returns to Bennett after leaving her fiance, determined to be independent for once in her life. After convincing her father to let her work for the family business, she soon realizes being a responsible adult isn't all it's cracked up to be. Loathed by her coworkers, neglected by her best friend, and held captive by a terrifying secret, she doesn't know how much more she can take. The lives of these two women, decades apart but uncannily similar, finally intersect one fateful night. With broken hearts and hope for the future, will they find the answers they're looking for?