Jay McMullen believes in family and fidelity, and wants to be with Lily forever because she is the only woman he has ever loved. But when she drops out of his life without one word of explanation, he is confronted with the reality that his life might not work out as perfectly as he had hoped. Decades later, Lily comes back into his life, and he's faced with a decision. The story of a man who always did the right thing, until he's thrown into a situation where the wrong thing might be the only way for him to feel whole again.