For most, Bayfield is a quaint, unassuming harbor town. For some, the decades-old headlines alleging unexplainable sightings of strange creatures in the water tell a different story. For a select few, the truth behind these legends, speculations, and folklore is more than a mere mystery: There's magic in the bay. And for local fisherman Mr. Winslow Hoffner, it's all just a matter of finding yourself in the wrong place at the right time...