When Sharrae first met Troy in high school, it was love at first sight for her. Troy was popular, attractive, and a wrestling team champion. Although nothing happened between them, she always wondered about what might have been. Twenty years later, when Sharrae runs into Troy again, her feelings resurface, and she decides to take action and get to know the man she had loved so many years before. But as Troy and Sharrae's relationship blossoms, Sharrae realizes that not all is as it seems to be. More and more frequently, Troy begins blowing off dates and holiday gatherings-not to mention the fact that he may be involved with married women. Although Sharrae often asks Troy to stop playing games and tell her the truth, he eludes her questions, swearing that she is the only girl for him. After six years in an on-again, off-again romance, Troy asks Sharrae to marry him. Although she's elated at the possibility of spending the rest of her life with him, she faces a choice: accept the man of her dreams and the emotional price that comes with the relationship, or find the strength within herself to let him go in hopes that a better man waits for her.