After defeating Lucifer and sacrificing the love of her life, Jack, Schuyler wakes up back in New York safe and sound. Only it's not quite the New York she knows. She discovers that in this world, her best friend has a different last name, her parents are both alive and well and one of them is an entirely different person, and the love of her life is alive, but with no idea who she is. This is an alternate reality where Lucifer is alive and acting as mayor, with Jack as his right hand man. Just when she thinks all is lost, Schuyler is contacted by a familiar friend - the Silver Blood, Kingsley.