September 1963: Pastor David Elliott finds himself investigating an execution-style slaying. Eight years ago, the victim falsely accused David's close friend of sexual abuse of a young girl. Now that friend's son is charged with the murder. David's efforts to prove his innocence provokes friction with police investigators, an influential church member, and David's own life decisions. Meanwhile, two whip-smart women join David in the quest for the truth. The trio's search propels them along a treacherous path with little to rely on but their sharp wits. To find the crafty killer in time to save their friend, the girl in the orange maillot is the key.